School Safety (part 2)

We received an update this afternoon on how our schools were planning on handling students who want to join the planned protest on Wednesday in support of the victims of the recent Parkland tragedy.   It sparked a lot of discussion and as expected a broad range of opinions.  In summary it seems like most of the discussion was primarily in two specific areas……

Should (and if so how can) schools best support students who wish to participate in the 17 Minutes of Silence Protest on Wednesday?   As expected there were strong opinions on both sides. 

On one hand, there were individuals who took the position that there should be no debate about allowing students to walk out of class and participate with no fear of reprisal – it just “common sense” that we should support it.  “After all”, they stated “How can we stop them anyway and who wants to hear in the press about our school refusing to support such a tragedy.”  A bad reasoning statement from one individual for sure, but I could be convinced that out district should allow it if students were truly doing it to be supportive and not just joining the “bandwagon” or wanting a break from class.  Although I struggle a bit with exactly who and how that determination would be made……

Folks with a differing point of view wondered aloud whether schools would be as supportive for other causes that were important to students.  The thinking that was articulated was that unless the school was prepared to be supportive of all causes, this one cause should not receive any preferential treatment, no matter how horrific the circumstances.  The sentiment seemed to be that the focus should be on maintaining a normal day of operation and that regular consequences outlined in school policies should remain in place for anyone who chooses to leave class.  I can also see some validity in this argument as well, although I don’t at the high school how it could really be stopped….

In both scenarios, one matter of great concern remains student safety (and                cynically for some who is liable if something were to happen during the walk out if the school supported it). 

Is it easier to maintain student safety, the routine of the rest of the day and the relationships between student and staff if the school is supportive and helps to facilitate a process for those interested in participating?   or …..  Is it better for the school to remain neutral and maintain a normal operating day with enforcement of all rules and guidelines?

No easy answers but interested to see what  the final solution looks like.   It was very interesting to participate in the discussion and I am sure there is more to come….

2 thoughts on “School Safety (part 2)

Add yours

  1. My school district put out a letter that was very supportive of the demonstration, and said that the principals would work with the faculty and students to make sure it was safe, but it was vague enough not to mention whether there would be consequences.

    I saw that at least one HS in Texas was planning to issue 3-day suspensions to anyone who walked out. That’s the sort of thing that can end up at the Supreme Court. I hope the students follow through and take their medicine there. I’m one of the lunatic 10% that believe we should work towards eliminating all guns from civilian ownership, even if it takes 100 years.

    Like

  2. A great & timely discussion. Thank you.
    I personally loved some of the posts I saw on Twitter today of classroom teachers taking time to collaborate with students on what they could do FOR others during the 17 minute walk out – as an alternative to walking away from school. I saw many “Walk UP” movements – Instead of walking out for instance, “walk up to someone who looks lonely and say hello” “Walk up to a classmate and offer help” etc

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Website Powered by WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: